High Court decides 'Palace letters' written during the Whitlam dismissal can be accessed by historian Jenny Hocking

| 29.05,20. 05:30 PM |

High Court decides 'Palace letters' written during the Whitlam dismissal can be accessed by historian Jenny Hocking

A royal connection to Gough Whitlam's dismissal in 1975 has long been alleged, but remains unproven.(National Archives Of Australia)

Historian Jenny Hocking has won her High Court bid to access the letters exchanged between then governor-general Sir John Kerr and the Queen around the time of the dismissal of the Whitlam government.

Until now, the National Archives of Australia had refused to release the documents, known as the "Palace letters", saying they were private papers.

But Professor Hocking told the High Court correspondence between a governor-general and a monarch was the property of the Commonwealth, and not private.

In a majority ruling, the High Court agreed with Professor Hocking, and found the letters to be Commonwealth records.

"I'm absolutely delighted," Professor Hocking said.

Letters could provide insight into Whitlam government dismissal

Gough Whitlam speaks on the Parliament House steps
Gough Whitlam speaks outside Parliament House in Canberra after his government's dismissal on November 11, 1975. The release of the Palace letters may shed light on what happened.(Australian Information Service/National Library Of Australia: Nla.Pic-An24355082)

Today's ruling means Professor Hocking will finally be able to view the letters, which could hold important information about Australia's history.

The reasons for the dismissal of the Whitlam government in 1975 have long been debated, and these letters may provide clarity about what the Queen knew about Australia's greatest constitutional crisis.

"It's a story that has been absolutely clouded in secrecy, in distortion and in so much unknown," Professor Hocking said.

"With this decision, one of those last remaining areas of secrecy and great unknown will be released to the Australian public."

Alongside the correspondence between the Queen and Sir John known as the "Palace letters", the National Archives also holds telegrams and attachments like newspaper clippings, exchanged between August 15, 1974 and December 5, 1977.

The material was deposited in 1978, after Sir John left the office, by Sir David Smith, the official secretary to the governor-general.The letters were due for release 12 years ago, but, because they had been marked as "private" correspondence rather than "Commonwealth records", they were not covered by the rules binding Commonwealth documents.

"Without this High Court decision, we were in the most extraordinary situation where pivotal historical documents were kept in our own archives and embargoed by the Queen," Professor Hocking said.

"This historic decision has overturned that. It reasserts Australian law over Australian archives and it also challenges … royal secrecy, where the activities of the monarch have been able to be shrouded in secrecy through the notion of confidentially and personal records."

End of a long battle for Hocking

A woman wearing glasses.
Professor Jenny Hocking has won her High Court bid.(AAP: Peter Rae)

Today's win comes after a series of court battles, since Professor Hocking first sought access to the letters in 2016.

Professor Hocking had already lost a Federal Court bid to overturn the decision to keep the letters private, which was made by the National Archives.

During the High Court hearing in February, Professor Hocking acknowledged the long legal process, but she was delighted to have had the case heard by the highest legal court in Australia.

"It's about our history, it's about our knowledge of our history, but it's also about having control over our own national archival resources," she said.

Professor Hocking's lawyers told the High Court that the documents were created and received by the governor-general as part of his official job, and therefore were the property of the Commonwealth.

"[The] evidence did not show that any person who dealt with the records or similar correspondence between a governor-general and the Queen perceived that the Australian copy of those records was the personal property of the person who was governor-general," the submissions read.

The High Court was also told there was a constitutional issue if a governor-general were to derive personal property in his communications with the Queen while in office.

Sir John Kerr speaks in front of a microphone in the middle of the SCG during the 1974 NSWRL Grand Final.
The letters between Sir John Kerr (pictured) and the Queen can now be accessed.(National Library Of Australia/Ern McQuillan)

The judgement was delivered in Brisbane this morning, because COVID-19 restrictions have prevented the bench to travel to the High Court of Australia in Canberra.

Professor Hocking received the news in Melbourne, and is planning to travel to Canberra to access the letters soon.

"I really look forward to going into the archives next week and speaking to the director-general … and ensuring that I can see all 211 of these Palace letters as soon as the National Archives reopens," she said.

"But as biographer and a historian, what is most pleasing to me is that we will have sorts of documentation that we need to write accurate history."


(Votes: 0)

Other News

Government to pay back $721m as it scraps Robodebt for Centrelink welfare recipients Rural telehealth Medicare rebates 'here to stay' past September says Federal Regional Health Minister Victoria toughens coronavirus work-from-home directives to keep people out of offices for June oronavirus restrictions in NSW to be eased for wedding, funerals and religious services NSW Government forecast shows coronavirus to slash up to $20 billion from state's economy Two dead in car crash at Menai in south Sydney Alleged Sydney criminal boss arrested, due in court on drug and weapons charges Queensland fisherman set out for trip and never returned Desperate search continues Reserve Bank asks for extension of controversial JobKeeper program Police shoot man dead following 'stand-off' on Melbourne's Monash Freeway Two malnourished teenagers found locked inside Brisbane house, man found dead in yard Man charged with murder of another man near Kempsey to face Coffs Harbour Local Court Woman found dead inside Eagleby home, south of Brisbane Scott Morrison refuses to make guarantees as he seeks workplace pay and conditions overhaul NSW Police could face class action over unlawful strip searches NSW Government freezes staff salaries to save $3 billion amid coronavirus pandemic Sydney man charged over murder of Nicole Cartwright, whose body was found dumped in park in 2018 Young girl thought she was 'going to die' in cow attack near Geelong Sydney man and woman charged over alleged baby formula theft Coronavirus: WA port workers may have been exposed to infected Al Kuwait ship crew NSW coronavirus cases confirmed at Waverley College and Moriah College in Sydney's east Mascot Tower owners vote to sue neighbouring property developer Aland over cracks NSW Government secures $21m for domestic violence support during coronavirus lockdown Human trials of potential coronavirus vaccine begin in Melbourne Beaumaris alleged hit-run: Man charged over death of cyclist Deborah Locco Queenslanders told to 'expect some colder weather' after record-breaking weekend Delivery drivers seen cycling through busy tunnels as cars and trucks speed past Prime Minister Scott Morrison to warn of hard economic recovery post-coronavirus WA unlocked to travellers as almost all regional restrictions set to end for long weekend Thousands of homes still without power after storm batters Perth and south-west WA