Black Saturday bushfire victims lose Federal Court tax case, ordered to pay ATO tax liability

| 28.02,19. 04:47 PM |

Black Saturday bushfire victims lose Federal Court tax case, ordered to pay ATO tax liability

Photo: The 2009 Black Saturday bushfires were the most devastating in Australian history, with 180 lives lost. (ABC TV)

Survivors of Victoria's deadly Black Saturday bushfires will be charged tax on interest accrued on their record payouts, the Federal Court has ruled.

The 2009 Black Saturday bushfires were the most devastating in Australian history, with 180 lives lost.

Lawyers for survivors had sought advice on whether to challenge the Australian Taxation Office (ATO) decision to tax the interest on a $300 million settlement for Murrindindi-Marysville victims, which was approved in 2015.

The case will also have implications for the almost $500 million settlement that was approved in December 2014 for the Kilmore East-Kinglake fire victims.

About 5,000 victims sued electricity provider SP AusNet, Utility Services Corporation Limited and the Department of Sustainability and Environment after more than 100 people died in the East Kilmore-Kinglake fires in February 2009.

Law firm Maurice Blackburn and the ATO had been tied up in negotiations on the interest owed, and after they failed to come to an agreement, the firm's head of class actions, Andrew Watson, launched a case against the ATO in the Federal Court on March 28, 2018.

Maurice Blackburn received tens of millions of dollars' worth of fees from the Marysville class action and the Kinglake class action.

The tax liability has been reported as being as high as $20 million.

Judge rules this was no commercial venture

In the financial year ended June 30, 2016, Mr Watson, acting in his capacity as scheme administrator of the Fund, derived $8,355,722 in interest income when fund money was deposited in a series of term deposits and other interest-bearing bank accounts.

The Fund also incurred $4,341,327 in costs and expenses during the relevant year, comprised almost entirely of Maurice Blackburn staff billable hours.

Mr Watson claimed he was entitled to deduct the outgoings from the assessable income of the Fund in the relevant year, being the interest income.

He argued he was "vastly experienced in administering schemes of this kind"; had maximised returns, engaged up to 49 people to assist him in the administration, and "established databases for the management and administration".

His expectation was that the administration costs could be paid out entirely from the interest, and he argued this was indicative of the carrying on of a business.

The Court rejected that argument and dismissed the appeal application.

Justice Middleton said expenses for which he claimed the deductions related to the distribution of the Fund, not to deriving income from bank deposits.

He added: "I do not consider that the activities of the Taxpayer (Mr Watson) properly identified, were of a commercial character."

"I am not persuaded that there existed a profit-making purpose which motivated the Taxpayer's (Mr Watson's) activities."

The judge said, "As was put by the Commissioner in the course of oral submissions, this is not a profit-making purpose in the ordinary, commercial sense".

Maurice Blackburn Lawyers class action spokesman Cameron Scott said they were disappointed with the outcome and were considering an appeal.

"This was an issue we had to test, because it meant either accepting that there was nothing more for bushfire survivors or fighting to extract every last bit of financial support for them we could," he said.

"We are obviously disappointed with the outcome and we will be discussing the possibility of appealing the decision of the Federal Court with our legal advisers."


(Votes: 0)

Other News

Two men charged after former NSW detective shot in face in Melbourne Kerri-Anne Kennerley's husband John dies in Sydney's St Vincent's Hospital 'Simply daft': Man who towed boat down highway with mobility scooter escapes jail time WestConnex tunnel traffic set to be higher than expected, data shows Sixth person charged over alleged police bashing in Melbourne Interest rates set to be slashed as jobless rate rises, big banks warn Ita Buttrose to be named new ABC chair, ending months of leadership uncertainty at the public broadcaster George Pell taken to prison after bail revoked at court hearing for child sex offences George Pell could begin time behind bars as court considers possible jail sentence Police raid motel near Byron Bay after former cop shot in face Property investors battered by a 'perfect storm' of falling prices and tighter credit Elderly woman dies after being struck by train in Brisbane's east Boys' bodies found together in Qld river Warning issued over popular dummies due to strangulation fears Labor proposes crackdown on 'dirty money' laundered through Australian real estate Police hunt for man who spat at officer in St Kilda assault where officer's head was 'smashed against the ground' Newspoll unchanged: Labor leads Coalition Police investigate sudden death at Murdoch University’s South Street campus There are more properties on the market now than at any time since 2012 — and no-one's buying Labor to hit banks and financial institutions with $640 million levy Five taken to hospital from 'high risk' Ultra Music festival in Parramatta Man, 29, charged over alleged sexual assault of young girl Newspoll unchanged: Labor leads Coalition Tourist dies after falling through church skylight at Surfers Paradise Dozens rescued from south-east Queensland beaches as ex-Tropical Cyclone Oma departs Brisbane father disappears from Egypt prison on week of release Oma downgraded, moves away from Qld coast We should be able to choose': Australian firefighter Troy Thornton dies in Swiss euthanasia clinic Opal Tower residents could wait months before repairs are finished Canberra Aeronautical Club member hospitalised after NSW plane crash