Malcolm Turnbull's backdown on Paris emissions target fails to appease Coalition detractors

| 18.08,18. 04:36 PM |

Malcolm Turnbull's backdown on Paris emissions target fails to appease Coalition detractors

The Prime Minister's backdown on energy policy has not placated some rebels in the Coalition party room who continue to criticise government policy and threaten to cross the floor.

The fraught debate within the Coalition has fuelled speculation about a possible leadership challenge, but Home Affairs Minister Peter Dutton today declared his support for Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull and his policies.

Last night, Mr Turnbull capitulated to pressure from as many as 10 MPs who remained opposed to the National Energy Guarantee, dumping a plan to embed emissions-reduction targets in legislation.

To appease the critics Mr Turnbull will instead propose to set the targets by regulation, which means backbench MPs with concerns will not be forced to vote against the targets in Federal Parliament.

But that change, which is something the Labor states have been calling for, has only added to concerns from some Nationals that the Opposition will simply ratchet up the target from 26 to 45 per cent if they win office.

Government frontbencher and Nationals MP Keith Pitt has repeatedly refused to rule out quitting his role to oppose the policy on the floor of Parliament.

Nationals Senator John Williams said he was "very concerned" by the change, as it would allow Labor to easily increase the emissions-reduction targets if it won office.

Nationals MP Andrew Gee repeated his threat to cross the floor and said he was frustrated Labor had been provided with more details than backbenchers.

"I have been raising my concerns for a number of days and no-one has contacted me with any other proposals or any detail of anything on the table," he said.

Nationals MP George Christensen said the Government appeared to have reacted to backbench concerns, but did not think the changes "went in the right direction".

Liberal MP Craig Kelly, who has been one of the most vocal critics of the policy along with former prime minister Tony Abbott, said the policy could "make things worse, not better".

Mr Abbott told 2GB dumping the plan "for God knows what reason" would "just let an incoming Labor government come in and be able to increase [the target] willy-nilly, which is the last thing we should be doing".

"I've got to say that it's no way to run a Government — making absolute commitments on Tuesday and breaking them on Friday," he said.

Only this week, Mr Turnbull fiercely defended the plan to legislate the Paris targets, saying to do otherwise would deny Parliament "a voice".

Dutton reaffirms support for PM

After days of speculation, Mr Dutton released a statement on social media playing down reports he was considering calls to challenge Mr Turnbull.

The Daily Telegraph reported today some Coalition MPs expressed their concerns about the Government's fortunes, and that they would support Mr Dutton if he did make a move.

"In relation to media stories today, just to make it very clear, the Prime Minister has my support and I support the policies of the Government," Mr Dutton said.

On Thursday, Mr Dutton gave an interview that raised some eyebrows because he said if he did not agree with a policy then he would resign.

But senior Coalition figures said he was merely explaining cabinet process, rather than an intention.

Former deputy prime minister Barnaby Joyce also supported the Prime Minister today, saying he did not believe there should be a change of leadership.

"I think that Malcolm is what we need to try and make sure we get a steady ship and that's precisely what I want," Mr Joyce said.

"I didn't support Malcolm getting rid of Tony [Abbott], I thought it was stupid Julia [Gillard] getting rid of Kevin [Rudd], and I thought Kevin getting rid of Julia looked even more dopy.

"When you start chopping and changing like that … it really should be the realm of the person who holds the office, not the realm of others."

Turnbull has lost control: Butler

While the proposed change has concerned some Coalition backbenchers, it's been welcomed by Federal Labor.

Shadow Energy Minister Mark Butler said the Federal Government was unravelling over energy policy, with internal divisions now becoming public.

"A series of humiliating backflips and backdowns by a Prime Minister who has completely lost control of his own Government — a Government that is an utter shambles," Mr Butler said.

Federal Labor has not declared whether it will support the National Energy Guarantee in Parliament, but Mr Butler said setting the targets by regulation was a good idea.

"This is not a Government idea, Labor has been arguing this point now for weeks," he said.

"It will make it easier for a future Labor Government, or frankly a future Liberal Government that is not beholden to the hard-right, to lift these targets in the future as inevitably will be required," he said.

Government pushes back on 'stroke of pen' criticism

Deputy Prime Minister Michael McCormack said if a minister did want to increase the emissions-reduction target by regulation, it would not be a simple process.

The Government would first need to ask the energy regulator and the consumer watchdog to prepare a report on how that decision would impact on power prices.

The minister would also need to give a statement to Parliament explaining the decision, which would then be debated.

"It would have to go to the public to explain what, if any, difference that would make," Mr McCormack told the ABC.

"Of course if you increase the emissions target, you are going to increase prices."


(Votes: 0)

Other News

Police car rammed, motorcycle officer driven off road in separate incidents Dutton denies plotting to overthrow Turnbull As PM risks leadership with electricity plan Gun law changes dropped by Tasmanian Liberals following community backlash Pilot dies in waterbombing helicopter crash on NSW south coast Two split record $100m Powerball jackpot AFIC Press Release with regards to Senator Anning’s maiden speech in Parliament Time to invest in a solar battery system or upgrade your existing system? Woman accused of murdering rapper in Sydney street granted bail Rising out-of-pocket medical costs force more than 1m Australians to put off doctor visits: report New Zealand bans foreigners from buying property in effort to clamp down on house price growth NSW bushfires: Emergency warnings issued for fires near near Croobyar and north Nowra Senator honours White Australia Policy in first speech and calls for 'final solution' on immigration National Energy Guarantee endorsed by Coalition party room despite backbench concern Call for inquiry after man with Down syndrome dies outside hospital New tech surveillance laws more a 'side gate' than 'back door' into Australian phones Sydney trains: Number of people caught 'surfing' on public transport doubles in past year they search for a man wanted for serious offencesSiege underway in Wallaroo as SA Adelaide driver fined for transporting wardrobe in boot and using clothes as rope Man arrested over hit-and-run that killed young Dutch cyclist in Chapel St Message from the President-Muslim Australia-AFIC Dr Rateb Jneid on the occasion of Eid UlAdha 2018 Woman goes blind in one eye from cosmetic filler injected in face Police release image of man after cyclist dies in hit-and-run in inner Melbourne NBN customers paying for FTTP upgrade giving neighbours cheaper access 'Peaceful' inner-Sydney suburb shaken by daylight killing Nimbin camper's body believed found at Blue Knob Mountain Police raid Fourth Reich clubhouse south of Wollongong Teens charged over series of carjackings, robberies in Melbourne's south-east Man sentenced to 24 years' jail for murdering teen found in mineshaft Sydney shooting: Police lock down part of inner-city Sydney after man found dead on street States give conditional support to National Energy Guarantee, but more talks to come