Solicitor-General to check if Peter Dutton is in breach of constitution

| 22.08,18. 09:40 PM |



Solicitor-General to check if Peter Dutton is in breach of constitution


Photo: Attorney-General Christian Porter is understood to have asked the Solicitor-General for advice. (ABC News: Matt Roberts)

Attorney-General Christian Porter has called on the Government's chief lawyer for advice on whether Peter Dutton is eligible to remain in Parliament.


Earlier this week, as speculation Mr Dutton was preparing to mount a leadership challenge was reaching fever pitch, Network Ten reported concerns about the Queensland MPs constitutional status.


Mr Dutton's register of members' interests shows he is the beneficiary of a family trust with interests in childcare centres in Queensland.


Those centres, like many around the country, receive Commonwealth subsidies.


Constitutional lawyers, including Professor Anne Twomey, suggest Mr Dutton could be under an eligibility cloud due to the ban on members and senators benefitting financially from the Commonwealth.


That rule is contained in section 44(5) of the constitution, and includes both direct and indirect financial gain.


During Question Time, the Prime Minister was peppered with questions from Labor about the reports.


"I'm advised by the Attorney-General that advice has not been sought from the Solicitor-General," Mr Turnbull said in response.


"The matter has only arisen in very recent times, we are not in possession of all of the facts relating to the arrangements between the childcare centre and the Member for Dickson's trust.


"But it is an issue of the eligibility for the Member for Dickson, he has legal advice, which I have said I have not read it."


However, Attorney-General Christian Porter has now confirmed he has asked the Government's most senior lawyer, Solicitor-General Stephen Donaghue QC for advice on the matter.


"Given that today the subject of a member's eligibility was raised in Question Time and in media reports, I determined to seek advice from the Solicitor-General on the issues raised," Mr Porter said in a statement.


Earlier this week, Mr Dutton said he had his own legal advice suggesting he was not in breach of the constitution.


If the issue was to be dealt with by the High Court, it would require the House of Representatives to vote to refer Mr Dutton's matter for judgment.


Section 44(5) is the same part of the nation's founding document that brought former South Australian senator Bob Day undone.


The High Court ordered his disqualification from the Senate last year, after ruling leasing arrangements for his Adelaide electoral office breached the constitution.


abc


(Votes: 0)

Other News

Message of His Excellency Bishop Antoine - Charbel Tarabay In response to the severe drought in New South Wales Petrol prices climb to four-year high, ACCC urges motorists to use comparison apps Malcolm Turnbull hangs on with 48-35 leadership ballot win over Peter Dutton, reshuffle on the cards NSW Premier Gladys Berejiklian announces Climate Change Fund money to reduce energy costs Corrigin crash kills mother, 10yo son after semi-trailer slams into parked car Salt Ash bushfire in NSW upgraded to emergency as residents are warned it is too late to leave Victoria Police offer $500,000 reward to solve brutal sexual assault in North Melbourne Malcolm Turnbull's backdown on Paris emissions target fails to appease Coalition detractors Police car rammed, motorcycle officer driven off road in separate incidents Dutton denies plotting to overthrow Turnbull As PM risks leadership with electricity plan Gun law changes dropped by Tasmanian Liberals following community backlash Pilot dies in waterbombing helicopter crash on NSW south coast Two split record $100m Powerball jackpot AFIC Press Release with regards to Senator Anning’s maiden speech in Parliament Time to invest in a solar battery system or upgrade your existing system? Woman accused of murdering rapper in Sydney street granted bail Rising out-of-pocket medical costs force more than 1m Australians to put off doctor visits: report New Zealand bans foreigners from buying property in effort to clamp down on house price growth NSW bushfires: Emergency warnings issued for fires near near Croobyar and north Nowra Senator honours White Australia Policy in first speech and calls for 'final solution' on immigration National Energy Guarantee endorsed by Coalition party room despite backbench concern Call for inquiry after man with Down syndrome dies outside hospital New tech surveillance laws more a 'side gate' than 'back door' into Australian phones Sydney trains: Number of people caught 'surfing' on public transport doubles in past year they search for a man wanted for serious offencesSiege underway in Wallaroo as SA Adelaide driver fined for transporting wardrobe in boot and using clothes as rope Man arrested over hit-and-run that killed young Dutch cyclist in Chapel St Message from the President-Muslim Australia-AFIC Dr Rateb Jneid on the occasion of Eid UlAdha 2018 Woman goes blind in one eye from cosmetic filler injected in face Police release image of man after cyclist dies in hit-and-run in inner Melbourne