Malek Fahd Islamic school appeal dismissed by full Federal Court bench

| 20.03,18. 06:49 PM |

Malek Fahd Islamic school appeal dismissed by full Federal Court bench

Photo: The Malek Fahd Islamic School in Sydney's south-west has had its future in doubt for the past two years. (ABC News: Johanna Nicholson)

Malek Fahd Islamic school in Sydney's west had its funding cut two years ago by Federal Education Minister Simon Birmingham over poor governance issues and because it was operating for profit.

The school of 2,500 kindergarten to Year 12 students, which has its largest campus in Greenacre, had been able to keep going due to interim appeals in lower courts, internal reforms including a change of board and an overhaul of its relationship with its landlord, the Australian Federation of Islamic Councils.

The Federal Court today upheld an earlier judgement by the NSW Administrative Appeals Tribunal.

In applying to appeal the matter, the school argued "things had changed under its new management" and the school was no longer operated for profit, the judgement said.

"The [Education] Minister accepted that some things had changed as a result of the change in [Malek Fahd's] management, but maintained that the school continued to be operated for profit," the judgement said.

'All schools must comply': Minister

In a written statement issued today, Mr Birmingham said all schools must comply with the Education Act.

"All school authorities must meet the requirements of the Education Act and ensure that our taxpayer dollars and any private investment by parents is being spent to benefit Australian students," he said.

The school's board chair John Bennett said he was extremely disappointed in the decision.

"It was a split decision by the full bench of the Federal Court. We now need to look at the decision and look at our options," he said.

"We will look at appealing the High Court.

"If that appeal fails we will not be able to afford to stay open," Dr Bennett said.

School to stay open for now

The school would continue operating during any appeal process, the chair explained.

"We are telling the parents and students that we are doing all we can — this is not the same school as two years ago," Mr Bennett said.

"I am fully supportive of the money provided by the Government being spent properly.

"But looking briefly at today's orders, we believe things have changed since last May's federal court hearing."

Dr Bennett said he would also look at appealing directly to the Education Minister.

Senator Birmingham said he had written to NSW Education Minister Rob Stokes to "work together to support the school's students, families and staff".


(Votes: 0)

Other News

Bushfire threat in Tathra subsides, but asbestos fears stop residents returning CBA, ANZ hauled over the coals at banking royal commission NSW fires: Warning for blaze near Bega downgraded as conditions ease Man sentenced to six years' jail for locking boy in shed on NSW mid-north coast drug farm CYCLONE MARCUS will reach a Category 2 level before it arrives in Dariwn AFIC Statement Regarding Sri Lanka & Other Attacks on Muslims Globally Helicopter crashes into ocean near Port Hedland off WA's Pilbara coast with one pilot missing Bankers forged customer signatures, faked documents and accepted cash bribes for loans, royal commission hears Stephen Hawking dies aged 76, family says Queensland on cyclone watch as flood clean-up continues in state's north Melanoma self-testing could save your life in just 90 seconds, experts say Queensland floods: Authorities warn of health risks as cost counting begins Sydney street shut down, witnesses treated after woman jumps from Sydney Tower Liberals release election policies, four days after election Negative gearing laws should exclude deductions for wealthy property investors 'Cruel and barbaric' man jailed for torturing and murdering stepdaughter Australia's largest privately owned cattle enterprise, Consolidated Pastoral Company, up for sale Retail Food Group stocks hit 10-year low on $88m loss and 200 stores to be closed Girl critical after electric shock from tap while watering garden Geraldton man jailed for 'chilling' knife attack on estranged wife and friend North-west Queensland hit with heavy rain, flooding after long-awaited downpour 'Go home and use heat pack', man with broken neck told Victorian becomes third person to die in rockmelon listeria outbreak A focus on responsible lending will uncover huge problems for the banks Listeria case in Tasmania could be linked to NSW rockmelons Khanh Ly sentenced to 18 years in jail for killing ex-girlfriend Miming Listiyani Find out if your car is at risk of an airbag explosion Maronite Eparchy of Australia A Safe Parish Workshop For Personnel working with Minors and Vulnerable Persons Perth Bunnings fire prompts chemical scare and evacuation of nearby homes 'Unusual' thunderstorm hits Perth's south, tearing off roofs, flooding homes